What is Kubernetes vs. EKS?
Kubernetes is open-source software that runs containers across a group of machines. Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service (EKS) is AWS’s managed service for running Kubernetes. So the two are not competitors. EKS is one way to run Kubernetes on AWS.
What Kubernetes does
Kubernetes decides which machine (node) should run each container, starts replacements when containers fail, scales the number of copies up and down, and routes network traffic to them. It also manages configuration and secrets.
Google created Kubernetes, drawing on its internal cluster manager, Borg. Version 1.0 was released in July 2015, and the project was donated to the Cloud Native Computing Foundation (CNCF). It ships about three minor releases a year. The upstream project supports each release for roughly 14 months.
A Kubernetes cluster has two parts:
- The control plane holds the API server, the etcd data store, the scheduler and the controller manager. It decides what should run and where.
- The worker nodes run your containers. Each node runs the kubelet, a network proxy and a container runtime.
What Amazon EKS is
Amazon EKS runs the Kubernetes control plane for you. AWS operates the control plane across several Availability Zones, and it replaces failed control plane components automatically. EKS became generally available in June 2018.
EKS runs standard, CNCF-certified Kubernetes. The same kubectl commands, Helm charts and manifests work on EKS and on other conformant clusters. EKS also connects Kubernetes to AWS services, such as IAM for access control, the VPC networking plugin for pod addresses, and load balancers for services.
What AWS manages and what you still manage
The main difference is who runs each layer:
| Layer | Self-managed on EC2 | Amazon EKS (standard) | EKS Auto Mode |
|---|---|---|---|
| Control plane (API server, etcd) | You | AWS | AWS |
| Worker nodes (operating system, scaling) | You | You | AWS manages the nodes |
| Your apps, manifests and configuration | You | You | You |
Even on EKS, you still configure your workloads, choose instance types or other compute options, and plan upgrades. Upgrades are one minor version at a time. Start with the control plane, then update the nodes and the add-ons.
Is EKS real Kubernetes?
Yes. EKS runs upstream Kubernetes that has passed the CNCF conformance tests, so manifests written for conformant Kubernetes usually run on EKS without changes. EKS is not a fork. The main limit is timing. EKS usually adds a new Kubernetes version a few weeks to a few months after the upstream release.
Kubernetes, EKS and ECS compared
Amazon Elastic Container Service (ECS) is a different orchestrator. It is AWS’s own product, so it is not Kubernetes.
| Self-managed Kubernetes | Amazon EKS | Amazon ECS | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Open-source orchestrator you run yourself | Managed Kubernetes on AWS | AWS’s own container orchestrator |
| Control plane fee | None for the software, but you run the servers | $0.10 per hour per cluster | None |
| Portability | Runs on many clouds and on-premises | Standard Kubernetes APIs, with AWS integrations | Specific to AWS |
| Learning curve | Highest | Moderate | Lower |
Cost, briefly
EKS adds a fixed control plane fee, and you pay for the worker nodes and the AWS resources they use. Self-managed Kubernetes avoids that fee but adds operating work. ECS avoids the fee too. The explanation of why EKS is so expensive covers the full bill.
When to choose which
- Choose EKS when you need Kubernetes features or tooling, want AWS to run the control plane, and can manage the workloads yourself.
- Choose self-managed Kubernetes when you need full control over the cluster, or need to run the same setup across clouds or on-premises, and have the team to operate it.
- Choose ECS when you want containers on AWS with the least operational work and do not need Kubernetes APIs.
If you decide on EKS, the EKS setup guide walks through creating a small test cluster and removing it.
Next steps
- Read can Kubernetes be used on AWS to see all the ways to run it there.
- Compare the ECS container deployment guide.