Google App Engine

Google App Engine vs AWS Elastic Beanstalk

App Engine or Elastic Beanstalk? Compare how each hides infrastructure, scales when idle, handles deployments, and bills, so you can pick one.

On this page
  1. What each service is
  2. Infrastructure visibility
  3. Scaling and idle cost
  4. Languages and platforms
  5. Deployments and rollback
  6. Configuration and command-line tools
  7. Access and customization
  8. Pricing and regions
  9. Which to choose
  10. Common misconceptions
  11. Next steps

Both services let you deploy application code without managing the platform underneath it. App Engine hides the infrastructure, can scale Standard apps to zero, and bills per instance-hour with a free quota. Elastic Beanstalk creates EC2 instances, load balancers, and Auto Scaling groups in your AWS account. You can see and customize those resources, but you pay for them even when the app is idle.

What each service is

App Engine is Google Cloud’s platform as a service. Google first previewed it in 2008. You deploy code, and App Engine runs it on managed infrastructure.

Elastic Beanstalk is AWS’s orchestration layer for deploying applications. AWS launched it in January 2011. You choose a platform and upload code, and Elastic Beanstalk provisions and manages the EC2 resources behind it. It is a deployment service, not a serverless one.

Infrastructure visibility

Elastic Beanstalk creates EC2 instances, Auto Scaling groups, load balancers, and CloudFormation stacks in your account, and you can inspect all of them. App Engine Standard hides the infrastructure, so you manage applications and versions rather than servers. App Engine Flexible runs on Compute Engine virtual machines, which you can connect to over SSH.

Scaling and idle cost

App Engine Standard can scale to zero, so an idle app can cost nothing beyond its free quota. Flexible cannot scale to zero, and at least one instance runs at all times.

Elastic Beanstalk cannot scale to zero either. An environment needs at least one EC2 instance, and single-instance environments are available for small apps. You pay for those instances whether or not they receive traffic.

Languages and platforms

Elastic Beanstalk offers platforms for Java, .NET on Windows and Linux, PHP, Node.js, Python, Ruby, Go, Tomcat, and Docker.

App Engine Standard supports Python, Java, Node.js, PHP, Ruby, and Go, with specific runtime versions. Flexible adds .NET and any language in a custom container.

Both services retire old platform and runtime versions on a schedule, so check the current list before you start a long-lived project.

Deployments and rollback

Elastic Beanstalk offers several deployment policies: all at once, rolling, rolling with an additional batch, immutable, and traffic splitting. Blue/green deployments work by swapping environment CNAMEs.

App Engine deploys each change as a new version. You can split traffic between versions by IP address, cookie, or at random. To roll back, you shift traffic to an earlier version, which is usually quick.

Configuration and command-line tools

Elastic Beanstalk reads .ebextensions/*.config files, .platform/ hooks, and a Procfile. You work with it through the eb CLI, using commands such as eb init, eb create, and eb deploy.

App Engine reads app.yaml, and optional files such as dispatch.yaml and cron.yaml. You deploy with gcloud app deploy.

Access and customization

Elastic Beanstalk gives you SSH access and full control of the EC2 instances, so you can install packages and change system settings. App Engine Standard has no SSH access. Flexible allows SSH and runs your own container image, which gives more control, but deployments still follow App Engine’s version and configuration model.

Pricing and regions

Elastic Beanstalk has no fee of its own. You pay for the EC2 instances, load balancers, EBS volumes, and other resources it creates. App Engine Standard includes a daily free quota of instance-hours and outbound traffic, then bills per instance-hour. Flexible bills for vCPU, memory, and disk, with no free quota.

Each App Engine application is tied to one region, and that choice cannot be changed later. Elastic Beanstalk environments can be created in any region.

The pricing guide covers App Engine costs in detail, and why AWS costs can climb explains the drivers on the AWS side.

Which to choose

Choose App Engine when:

  • You want the platform to manage infrastructure and you’re happy with a supported runtime.
  • Your app is idle much of the time, and you want it to scale to zero on Standard.
  • You want the Standard free quota for a small project.

Choose Elastic Beanstalk when:

  • You already run on AWS and want to use services such as RDS or SQS alongside your app.
  • You need SSH access and control over the EC2 instances.
  • You need a worker tier that consumes messages from Amazon SQS.

For a new containerized app on Google Cloud, compare App Engine with Cloud Run as well. If you’re deciding between App Engine’s environments, the Standard vs Flexible comparison covers the differences.

Common misconceptions

  • “Elastic Beanstalk is serverless.” It isn’t. You run and pay for EC2 instances, and they keep running unless you stop the environment.
  • “Elastic Beanstalk is free because it has no service fee.” Its underlying resources are billed.
  • “App Engine only runs Google’s languages.” Flexible runs any language in a container.
  • “Elastic Beanstalk is the closest AWS equivalent to App Engine Standard.” Serverless AWS options such as Lambda or App Runner are closer in model. Check App Runner’s availability for new customers before you plan around it.

Next steps

If you are starting with App Engine, the tutorial walks through a first deployment with the gcloud CLI. Once you have picked a service, the pricing guide helps you estimate the cost.

The complete guide to google app engine

Google App Engine Tutorial for Beginners
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →